Best 9 Wheel Hay Rake: Replacement Teeth and Wheel Kits Guide
Raking hay efficiently depends on the right combination of wheels and teeth. This guide highlights top 9-wheel hay rake components that fit a variety of makes and models, with a focus on durability, compatibility, and ease of maintenance. The selections below cover replacement rake teeth, rubber-mounted tines, and wheel kits designed for quick upgrades and reliable performance across common brands.
| Product | Brand | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| 18-Pack Wheel Hay Rake Teeth | Maple Farm Seats Inc | 3/8″ bolt holes, 7″ tine length, wide compatibility with John Deere, Darf, H&S, Sitrex, and more |
| Ag-Rite 55″ Rake Wheels — Set of 18 | Ag-Rite | USA-made, dual bolt patterns, fits many brands, 6 or 5.25″ PCD options |
| Premium American Made Rake Tines/Teeth | S&H PARTS | Fits New Holland 55″ rake wheels; durable tine construction |
| Reliable Aftermarket Parts 10 Heavy Duty Teeth | Reliable Aftermarket Parts | Rubber-mounted teeth, 3/8″ bolt compatibility, sturdy yoke and wire specs |
| Ag-Rite 55″ Rake Wheels Kit — 4 Left / 4 Right | Ag-Rite | USA-made, 7mm tines, two bolt patterns, strong wheel assemblies |
The following sections detail five highly compatible options for a 9-wheel hay rake setup, presenting practical specs and how they fit typical rakes across brands. Each product section includes a direct link to the Amazon listing, a visual reference, and essential features to compare before buying.
18-Pack Wheel Hay Rake Teeth by Maple Farm Seats

These replacement rake teeth provide broad compatibility for wheel rakes across major brands, including John Deere, Darf, H&S, Sitrex, and more. With a 3/8″ bolt hole, 7″ tine length, and a 9/32″ tine diameter, they are designed for straightforward installation and dependable performance in demanding field conditions. Cross-reference numbers align with common OEM parts, helping ensure a good fit for many model years. The kit is marketed with a customer-satisfaction focus and emphasizes comprehensive coverage for hay rake maintenance and quick part replacement.
Ag-Rite 55″ Rake Wheels — Set of 18

Made in the USA, these 55″ rake wheels come as a balanced set of 18 (9 left, 9 right) and feature dual bolt patterns to fit a wide range of rakes. The kit supports compatibility with multiple brands, including JD, Kubota, Kuhn, and Vermeer, among others. Two bolt patterns—6 bolt holes 0.4″ and 0.5″ dia—along with hub pilot holes, make them adaptable to many wheel configurations. The construction targets durability for extensive field use and straightforward installation for operators upgrading their rake assemblies.
Premium American Made Rake Tines for New Holland 55″ Rake Wheels

These tines are designed specifically for 55″ New Holland rake wheels and are sold as a reliable aftermarket option. The listing notes the product’s applicability to Duravee, Procart, HT152, HT154, and H5920 models, making them a practical upgrade for owners looking to restore performance on 55″ rake wheels. While the focus is on fit and durability, potential buyers should verify compatibility with their exact model before purchasing to ensure a precise match with mounting hardware and spacing.
Reliable Aftermarket Parts 10 Heavy Duty Teeth for New Idea Hay Rake

This set includes 10 heavy-duty rubber-mounted teeth, designed for parallel bar rakes with a 1 5/8″ bar. The package lists a 3/8″ bolt compatibility and specifies a 1-11/16″ yoke width with a 9/32″ wire diameter, aiming to deliver reliable hold and longevity during hay raking. The configuration supports rapid replacement and can help restore rake efficiency for New Idea and similar 9-wheel systems, especially where rubber-mounted teeth are preferred for vibration damping and smoother operation.
Ag-Rite Rake Wheels Kit 55″ — 4 Left / 4 Right Wheels

This paired wheel kit includes four left and four right wheels with 7mm tines, designed for 55″ rakes and a broad brand compatibility range. The kit emphasizes American-made quality and features dual bolt patterns to fit most rake configurations. It is marketed toward durability and reliability in demanding haying environments, helping operators replace worn wheels without compromising rake performance. Suitable for a variety of brands listed in the compatibility notes, the kit supports straightforward upgrading of an older rake assembly.
Ag-Rite Rake Wheels Kit 55″ — 4 Left / 4 Right (Alternative)

An alternative variant of the same 55″ wheel kit line, this option maintains the 7mm tine specification and USA-made construction. It also highlights compatibility with a wide array of brands and the same dual bolt pattern options to fit diverse rake frames. The emphasis remains on durable wheels and dependable tines to support consistent hay raking performance across seasons and field conditions.
Buying Guide
Key purchase considerations for 9-wheel hay rake components include compatibility, durability, and ease of installation. When evaluating teeth or tines, verify bolt hole size, tine length, and material quality to ensure longevity under typical field loads. For wheel kits, assess bolt pattern options, hub dimensions, and whether the set fits your rake’s brand and model year. Consider whether rubber-mounted teeth are preferred for vibration damping or if solid teeth suit your operation for higher-speed raking. Always cross-check OEM cross-reference numbers and read customer feedback about real-world fit and performance. If possible, confirm return or support options in case of fit issues.
In terms performance perspectives, universal-fit components offer broad compatibility but may require careful mounting alignment. Brand-specific parts tend to ensure a tighter fit but may limit options if you own multiple rake brands. A mixed approach—using high-quality replacement teeth with a versatile wheel kit—can optimize downtime, maintain raking efficiency, and extend the life of the rake assembly. For buyers balancing cost and durability, prioritize kits that provide durable metals, robust welds, and proven compatibility across the most common rakes in the field.
Additionally, consider supplier support and warranty terms. A seller emphasizing satisfaction and responsive support can help resolve issues quickly, minimizing downtime during critical harvest windows. When comparing options, create a brief column for fit, expected lifespan, and installation effort to guide a practical and objective decision.